
Aaron Irber
@aaronirber
Catholic Entomologist. Story respecter. Married w/ 4 kids. Host of I Might Believe in Faeries podcast. Check out my Substack - link below
ID: 984755615699480581
https://aaronirber.substack.com/ 13-04-2018 11:30:09
19,19K Tweet
1,1K Followers
1,1K Following





Aaron Irber It's possible that it's because it's not frenetic. Many children's books (and movies and TV shows) are. So are many books for grown-ups. Readers today don't know what to do with slow. To them, slow is a failure on the part of the author.

Aaron Irber I agree w/what someone else said… it’s about it’s poetic nature. If you don’t naturally think in metaphor &symbolism, it’s easy to get lost. That, plus the book requires a certain amount of “entering in” & big picture thinking, which is difficult in an external Twitter world.

Aaron Irber And those repeating the meme never even read Leaf by Niggle, the book where Tolkien technically does spend pages and pages describing a tree.

Aaron Irber Wow this really blew up. I think some lessons are: • Education has failed people profoundly. • People struggle to express preferences as preferences. • Tolkien genuinely isn't for everyone, though it might have been for many people who think it's not if they'd been educated.


Aaron Irber Hilary's analysis is largely correct. I'm old enough that I distinctly remember the advent of Del Rey books, the publication of The Sword of Shannara, and the horrible turn fantasy took at that point. Hilary is also right to point to the homogenization of genre publishing that







