
Diane O'Leary, PhD
@dianeoleary
Philosophy of medicine/phil of mind/bioethics. Rct visiting faculty @Center4PhilSci & @RotmanPhilo. Smtms disabled by chronic disease. Happy #IndependentScholar
ID: 98760855
https://www.dianeoleary.com 23-12-2009 01:13:54
3,3K Tweet
3,3K Followers
1,1K Following


Hey @NeilLevy10 I love your new paper, āConsciousness aināt all thatā. What a great read! Iām not convinced by yr challenge to my argument (or Kriegelās or Siewertās) on the moral value of consciousness but it's clear I need to sort out why. Working on it. link.springer.com/article/10.100ā¦

I had a marvelous conversation with the brilliant Jazmine Russell , who hosts the Depth Work Podcast. The episode is "The Mind-Body Problem in Psychiatry: How to Be a Holist". Very grateful for Jazmine's insights on my work, and on mental health generally podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/jazmiā¦


This long-Covid paper helps correct the most frequent/harmful mistake I've seen in my career- ie docs using psych diagnoses as a reflex default ("its all in your head") when can't nail a known cause for symptoms. Uncertainty always beats false certainty! thelancet.com/journals/lanmiā¦

āThe āmedical modelā is conflated with the idea that all medical conditions are discrete biological disease entities, an assumption that isnāt even true for much of general medicine, let alone psychiatry.ā (Awais Aftab) psychiatrymargins.com/p/people-are-sā¦

Pleased that Institute of Art and Ideas reposted my article on confusion abt dualism in medicine. I still don't get why people in philosophy of mind are so passive abt medicine's misunderstanding of dualism. That confusion is actually built into standards for patient care, and it does real harm.


Some excellent philosophical reasoning here frm Mark L. Ruffalo: psychiatry needs a foundation of nonreductive physicalism. Note this does involve property dualism, bc experiences are distinct from their correlated brain states. Prop dualism is in no way problematic for psychiatry!




Many thx Institute of Art and Ideas for posting my article. It doesn't say, tho, that mind-body dualism puts our health at risk! People often assume I'm rehashing that common idea, but no. I show how anti-dualism in medicine is based on bad philosophy, and how that confusion threatens our safety.

Thanks Symptomodyssee for posting this talk I gave at the 2023 RME conference! For those w ME & long covid I'd like to highlight the final section, starting around 25:10 - where I discuss the moral outrage people feel, rightly, abt problems with their med care. Hope it's useful.

HEY Institute of Art and Ideas! I've written to you several times to say that this tweet is inaccurate! Please, could you stop telling the world that I say "mind-body dualism puts our health at risk"? I argue the opposite, that medicine's fear of dualism puts health at risk. Read the article!